
5 Manuscript Formatting Mistakes That Can Delay Your Submission
5 Manuscript Formatting Mistakes
That Can Delay Submission
Most researchers expect rejection to
come from reviewers. Far fewer expect their paper to be sent back before a
single reviewer has opened it because the reference list follows the wrong
style or the title page is missing from the upload. It happens often, and the
cost is more than a few lost days. The paper has to be corrected and
resubmitted, and for a PhD scholar whose thesis chapter, progress review or
graduation requirement depends on that paper, even a short delay can create
difficulties.
This article walks through five
formatting mistakes that commonly hold up a manuscript submission, why journals
care about each one, and how to catch them before you click submit. It also
explains when a professional manuscript formatting service is genuinely useful
and when a careful read of the author guidelines is all you need.
What are the most common
manuscript formatting mistakes that delay submission?
The formatting problems that most often
hold up a manuscript submission are the ones a journal's office can see within
minutes of opening your files. These are the five covered below:
1. Ignoring
the target journal's author guidelines and using a generic template
2. Reference
lists that are inconsistent, incomplete or wrongly styled
3. Figures,
tables and captions that miss the journal's technical specifications
4. Incomplete
or misplaced front matter: title page, author details, declarations and
checklists
5. Wrong
file structure, including blinding errors, stray identifying details and length
limits
None of these says anything about the
quality of your science. They are administrative failures, which is exactly why
they are avoidable.
Why do formatting errors delay a
manuscript submission?
Because many journals run an
administrative or technical check before the paper is sent to an editor.
Springer Nature describes this first stage as an initial check that the
manuscript is readable, formatted properly and accompanied by the necessary
declarations, such as ethics statements and competing interests. Elsevier's
support pages describe a similar technical check at certain journals, where a
paper that fails is sent back with the specific reasons in an e-mail and must
be resubmitted with a response listing the changes.
The check is done by editorial staff,
not by subject experts, and it is checklist-driven. A missing declaration or an
unreadable figure is easy to spot, and the journal has no reason to send an
incomplete package to a busy reviewer. The paper simply waits until you fix it.
Two practical points follow from this:
·The
rules differ by journal. The International Committee of Medical Journal Editors
(ICMJE) offers widely used recommendations on manuscript preparation, but it
also says authors should use them together with each journal's own instructions
to authors.
·Revisions
are checked again. Springer Nature notes that a revised manuscript goes through
technical checks again, so sloppy formatting can cost you time more than once.
Mistake 1: Treating the author
guidelines as optional
The commonest journal formatting
mistake is also the least dramatic: the manuscript was prepared for a different
journal, or for no journal at all, and the author assumed the editorial office
would sort it out. Rejected papers are often recycled from one submission to
the next with only the cover letter changed, and old formatting travels along
with them.
What
this looks like in practice
·Section
headings that do not match the article type (a short communication written as a
full-length article, for example)
·Abstract
format that does not match the journal: structured versus unstructured, or the
wrong word limit
·Keyword
counts, running titles and highlights left out or over the limit
·Page,
word or reference limits exceeded. Some Elsevier-hosted guides state that the
page count includes abstract, references, tables, figures and appendix, and
that submissions outside the guideline may be returned for revision
·Word
or LaTeX files submitted in the wrong form. Springer journals using LaTeX, for
example, may expect the complete editable source files at every submission, and
one journal's guidelines state that incomplete source files mean the article
will not be considered for review
How
to avoid it
1.Read
the guide for authors for your journal and article type before you format
anything, not after the draft is finished.
2.Download
the journal's own template if one exists. Springer Nature, for one, encourages
its LaTeX template for LaTeX submissions.
3.Check
whether the journal offers a relaxed first submission. Wiley notes that most of
its journals offer Free Format submission, and Elsevier's Your Paper Your Way
lets references appear in any style as long as the style is consistent. Even
then, the journal's Guide for Authors states which approach applies, so confirm
it rather than assuming.
4.Make
a one-page checklist from the guide (limits, sections, file types,
declarations) and tick it off as you go. This is a tedious fifteen minutes that
saves a resubmission.
Mistake 2: Inconsistent or
incorrectly styled references
Reference lists are where journal formatting mistakes pile
up fastest, especially in long papers and theses converted into articles.
Reviewers and editors read an untidy list as a sign of an untidy paper, and
production teams struggle to match entries to indexing databases when details
are missing.
Common
reference problems
·Mixing
styles in one list (some entries in APA, others in Vancouver)
·In-text
citations that do not match the list: numbers out of order, or a citation with
no entry, or an entry never cited
·Missing
details: volume, pages, year, or the DOI
·Journal
names abbreviated inconsistently. Several Springer journals ask for the
standard abbreviation from the ISSN List of Title Word Abbreviations, or the
full title if you are unsure
·Reference-manager
field codes left in the Word file. Elsevier's support pages warn that these
codes can interfere with its PDF builder, so remove them before uploading
How
to fix them
Use a reference manager such as
Mendeley or Zotero, and load the journal's own citation style if one is
available. Then do a manual pass anyway. Reference managers copy whatever data
you imported, including the errors.
It is worth checking that every
reference list entry is actually cited in the text. Springer's guidelines for
several journals say the list should include only works cited in the text that
have been published or accepted for publication. Where a journal asks for DOIs
as full links, as many Springer titles do, add them at this stage rather than
at proof.
If the journal offers a free-format
first submission, a consistent style is still the minimum. Elsevier, for
instance, states that consistency is what its Your Paper Your Way approach
expects, and that for accepted articles it applies the journal style as long as
each reference carries complete and correct details.
Mistake 3: Figures, tables and
captions that miss the technical specifications
Figures are the part of a submission
most likely to fail for purely mechanical reasons. A graph that looked sharp on
your screen can come out pixelated in the review PDF, and a caption pasted
inside the image cannot be processed as text.
What
journals commonly ask for
Publishers publish exact artwork rules,
and they are worth reading once, carefully. Elsevier's artwork guidance is a
good example of the level of detail to expect:
Item
Elsevier
guidance
File formats
EPS, PDF, TIFF or JPEG, or Microsoft
Office files (Word, PowerPoint, Excel)
Resolution
300 dpi for halftones, 500 dpi for
combination art, 1000 dpi for line art
Line weight
Recommended 0.25 pt, absolute minimum
0.1 pt
Colour
RGB preferred, unless the journal's
guide says otherwise
File handling
Illustrations as separate files,
numbered in the order they appear in the text, with captions supplied
separately
Permissions
Rights cleared for both print and
electronic publication
Other publishers differ. Springer
Nature's common-issues guidance, for example, says figures and tables need
plain-text captions and a high resolution, and it lists missing image
permissions or credit as a frequent problem. The journal's own guide for authors
always has the final word.
Mistakes
to watch for
·Enlarging
a low-resolution image in a graphics program. Elsevier states that increasing
resolution this way never improves quality
·Pasting
a screenshot of a table instead of an editable table
·Embedding
the caption in the image file when the journal wants it as text
·Figures
not cited in the text, or cited in the wrong order
·Reusing
a figure from a published paper without written permission
·Faint
lines or text too small to read at final print size
Mistake 4: Incomplete or
misplaced front matter, declarations and checklists
This is the category where a good paper
gets returned for reasons that have nothing to do with its content. Springer
Nature lists missing contributing authors and missing ethics statements or
declarations among the common issues that stop a submission. Some Springer
journals go further and state that submissions without the relevant
declarations will be returned as incomplete.
Items
that are often missing or misplaced
·Title
page details.
Springer's journal guidelines ask for the title, each author's name and
affiliation (institution, department, city, country), and a clear indication
and active e-mail address for the corresponding author.
·Complete
author list.
Springer Nature advises including everyone involved in the research in the
initial submission, and some journals state that author changes or reordering
are not accepted after submission. Agree on the author list and order with your
co-authors before uploading.
·Competing
interests.
Elsevier's submission checklist asks for a competing interests statement even
when the authors have none to declare.
·Ethics,
funding and data statements.
Put these where the journal expects them, which is sometimes the manuscript and
sometimes a separate field in the submission system.
·ORCID
iDs. The
ORCID organisation reports that publishers have moved to require an iD for
corresponding authors, usually collected at submission. Springer Nature
encourages ORCID iDs, and Cambridge notes that co-authors have to authenticate
their own iDs rather than have the corresponding author add them.
·Reporting
checklists.
The EQUATOR Network, which maintains a library of reporting guidelines, notes
that many journals require a completed checklist at submission. A journal can
name its own: one Springer journal, for example, states that case reports must
follow the CARE guidelines and that submissions without the CARE checklist will
be returned as incomplete.
Mistake 5: Wrong file structure
and blinding errors
The last mistake is about how the
submission is packaged. Journals ask for different file sets, and a perfectly
formatted manuscript in the wrong arrangement still has to be fixed before
review.
File
structure
Some journals want one Word file with
embedded figures. Others want the manuscript text, each figure and each table
as separate uploads. Springer Nature's submission system, for instance,
describes a Word document with embedded images for some subject areas and a
zipped set of LaTeX files for others, while one Springer Nature clinical
journal's guidelines ask for separate files for each table and figure, and say
a PDF is not an acceptable manuscript format. Read the upload instructions for
the exact file types and order.
Blinding
errors in double-anonymised review
If your target journal uses
double-anonymised review, authors are responsible for removing identifying
details from the manuscript, and the checks go well beyond deleting names from
the first page. Wiley and Elsevier both ask for the title page to be uploaded
as a separate file, and their guidance covers the details authors forget:
·Remove
author names and affiliations from the main manuscript
·Cite
your own earlier work in a neutral way. Elsevier suggests wording such as
"[Anonymous, 2007]" in the text, with a placeholder in the reference
list. Wiley also asks for in-text references to previous work by the authors to
be anonymised
·Remove
funding sources and acknowledgements from the anonymised file, and place them
on the title page
·Check
file names and document properties for author names. Elsevier warns that almost
every file type you upload, apart from the title page, cover letter and LaTeX
source files, can be shared with reviewers
·Think
about preprints. A Wiley journal's guidelines warn that sharing a preprint may
compromise anonymity during peer review
The reverse mistake also happens:
authors blind a manuscript for a single-anonymised journal and leave out
affiliations or acknowledgements the journal wanted. Confirm which review model
applies. Wiley's help pages explain that if a required title page file appears
in the upload step, the submission is likely going to double-anonymised review.
Before
you upload
Open each file you plan to submit,
check its properties, and read the generated review PDF as a stranger would.
Ask a colleague to do the same if you can. They will notice what you stopped
seeing long ago.
Pre-submission checklist: what to
verify before you click submit
Use this as a final pass. Where a row
says "journal guide", the answer is whatever your target journal's
author guidelines state for your article type.
Area
What
to confirm
Where
to check
Article type
Sections, word count, abstract format
and display-item limits match the type you selected
Journal guide
Template and files
Correct file types, separate figure
or table files if required, LaTeX source complete
Journal guide, upload page
References
One style throughout, every in-text
citation has an entry and vice versa, DOIs added where requested, field codes
removed
Journal guide, reference manager
Figures and tables
Resolution, format, size, caption
placement, numbering, permissions for reused material
Publisher artwork guidance
Title page
Title, all authors in agreed order,
affiliations, corresponding author e-mail, ORCID iDs where asked
Journal guide, submission form
Declarations
Competing interests, ethics approval
and consent, funding, data availability, any AI-use statement the journal
asks for
Journal guide, submission form
Reporting checklist
CONSORT, PRISMA, STROBE, CARE or
other required checklist completed and attached
Journal guide, EQUATOR Network
Review model
Single- or double-anonymised, and the
manuscript prepared accordingly
Journal guide, submission system
Final read
Open every file as a reviewer would,
including properties and the generated PDF
Your own files
When is a manuscript formatting
service worth using?
A manuscript formatting service adjusts
your files to a specific journal's requirements: structure, references,
figures, title page and the supporting documents around them. It does not
change your findings or improve your argument. Publishers themselves treat
formatting support as ordinary author help; Springer Nature, for example, lists
manuscript and figure formatting among its author services.
It tends to be worth considering when:
·You
are converting a thesis chapter or a conference paper into a journal article
·A
paper has been rejected and you are moving it to a journal with a different
reference style, structure or review model
·You
are preparing a double-anonymised submission and are worried about missing
identifying details
·You
have many figures or tables with strict artwork rules
·Deadlines
are tight, for example, a funder report or a thesis submission date
You probably do not need one if your
target journal offers a relaxed first submission, your reference manager
already has the journal's style, and you have time to work through the guide
for authors yourself.
What
to look for in a service
·It
works from the journal's current guide for authors, not a general template
·It
leaves your scientific content and wording alone unless you ask for language
editing, and shows what it changed
·It
gives you a record of what was checked, such as a checklist covering
references, figures and declarations
·It
treats your unpublished data confidentially
·It
never promises acceptance. No formatting service can, and the decision remains
with the editors and reviewers
If you want a second pair of eyes before submission,
ManuscriptEdit's manuscript formatting service is built for this kind of
journal-specific preparation. You remain responsible for the content, the
author list and every declaration, so read the final files yourself before they
go in.
Reviews & Comments
No reviews yet. Be the first to write one.